Many of us were informed recently that a former professor at Cedarville is suing the University over his termination. He has also named at least one individual in the lawsuit as well, a university employee. The situation surrounding the termination has been one filled with controversy for over a year, and has been the subject of news reports, blogs, etc.
[This follows the actions of a Wheaton College tenured professor, who quit rather than share the reasons for his divorce from his wife with the school's authorities, as their community standards covenant would require. He has gone to the media to air his grievances and is questioning the ethics and legality of such inquiries, giving Wheaton a sharp public rebuke in the process. People are wondering if legal action will follow.]
I will not comment on the termination’s merits or procedure. As a teaching moment, however, let me take this sad occasion to remind all of our flock here at Grace that it is never appropriate for Christians to sue fellow Christians. Further, I believe it would be a “legal fiction” to try and say that suing a Christian-owned non-profit corporation is allowable because it is a corporation, not an individual.
The most pertinent scripture to guide us is found in 1 Corinthians 6:1-11, where Paul rebukes believers for taking their grievances before “the unrighteous” rather than believers. He says that this action brings shame on those who pursue it. He says that Christians should be able to solve their disagreements within the Christian community–the church. I know that this would be the local church initially, but what if the problem affects more than a local congregation? The pattern of the council of Jerusalem might suggest that in such a dispute a number of affected and concerned churches or a group of neutral believers could be called together, to function in some ways as the council in Acts 15 did–weighing issues and offering a solution.
To my knowledge, the Bible-believing churches or associations that have been directly or indirectly affected have not been asked to mediate in this situation, and I am unaware if any of the national Christian reconciliation ministries have been consulted either. These would be means available to uphold the spirit and letter of our text in the present difficulty.
Further, Paul tells the Corinthians that it would be better to be wronged than to take brothers and sisters to court to get one’s rights. Our belief that God is in control of all things, including evil done to us (see Genesis 50:20) allows us to suffer wrong as our Lord modeled while entrusting ourselves to the care of a loving and sovereign God. While I recognize that when sued we may be required to defend ourselves, the Scriptures do not justify taking legal action against a brother.
What about the issue of suing Christian owned and operated corporations? The text still applies, since the corporation is, in fact, a collection of Christians in its governors, its employees, and its constiuents–all of whom are negatively impacted by the action. This really becomes a distinction without a difference. If the courts render a punitive judgment against a Christian corporation, it is the Christians who own it, who work for it, and who make use of it that will suffer the consequences. So the person suing winds up injuring lots of people, not just one or two.
This is a sad case, and not one where, as I have said before, fault and wrong rests only on one side. However, biblical principles must govern the actions of Christians, even when those principles mean that we will suffer a wrong done by another Christian that is unjust, unfair, and would certainly be overturned by a court if we sued. We should seek reconciliation, mediation, and if agreeable, arbitration by believers. We should submit ourselves, individually or corporately, to such avenues if we are wronged or someone believes we have wronged them. If that is not available to us, however, we stand close to our Savior, who experienced far worse and sets the example for us. We should never give those in the world the excuse that believers can’t really live out the call of the gospel as a reason to mock our Lord or His teaching.
Let’s pray that this particular matter can be resolved biblically, outside of the legal system, to glory of the Savior who grieves over wrongs done to any of His children in any situation.